I want to start by saying that I am not an activist, I am not a psychologist nor particularly an expert in any of the fields involving what I'm about to write about. I'm just an LDS young woman who has felt entrenched in the complicated issue and wants to add my voice to the chorus sounding about it, if for no other reason than to articulate my own views for my own sake.
I hold a lot of complicated views on the issue of Ordain Women and what they support, and have felt both encouraged by and deeply hurt by Ordain Women's agenda and actions in my ever-shifting journey to inner peace on the subject. My opinion is not necessarily of interest to anyone, but it has become a largely shared topic on social media in recent weeks, and I feel like the time is right to make a second attempt at voicing my own viewpoint eloquently and with the tender wounds of those who disagree with me in mind (the first attempt was far less thoughtful and motivated by frustration earlier in my struggle to figure out my own thoughts).
I identified with some of Eric Samuelsen's recent post, though I felt his description of the 'second woman' was slanted and lacked 100% understanding of where she stands. But I feel a portion of what he describes. "This second woman is every bit as smart, every bit as tough-minded, every bit as thoughtful as my first hypothetical woman. But she’s not troubled by LDS sexism [...] And to her, the very existence of OW, or of other manifestations of Mormon feminism are laden with disrespect [...] to women like her. When you say the Church is manifestly sexist, you’re calling her entire worldview into question. You’re essentially saying she’s stupid. Or weak. Or unperceptive."
I've been trying to figure out why I feel this way about Ordain Women and what they represent. I am a feminist myself. I tend to say I practice feminism in moderation. I see inequality in the world around me and it frustrates and saddens me. I find sisterhood to be a key tool to be used against such inequality, possibly the single best weapon we have. And yet I wonder if the Adversary delights in OW for the conflict and opposition it has engendered in the hearts of some of the church's brightest, most forward-thinking members.
Maybe you can start to see how fitful I've been over the whole thing.
In an interview following her excommunication, Sister Kelly said, “…I do not acknowledge that God recognizes the decision…I don’t think these men have control over that.”
I am not surprised by this statement; since the beginning of this movement, I have tried to follow OW's way of thinking to understand it. If I were to agree with the following: 1. Women deserve the priesthood but the leaders will not allow it. -- then I would find myself agreeing with the following: 2. Because the leaders will not allow it, they are not truly in touch with nor following God. 3. Because they are not truly God's disciples, the entire church is a heart-wrenching, pain-inducing lie.
I simultaneously marvel at and am bewildered by those who agree with point 1 but do not follow it to point 3. Maybe I am too simple-minded -- I'm not proud quite to a fault, I won't rule it out as a possibility. Many, many, many -- hordes, in fact -- of people I've met in this church are far more spiritually intelligent than I am. For me, this is sort of along the same line as the old addage 'If the Book of Mormon is true, then Joseph Smith must be a prophet. If Joseph Smith is a prophet, then, etc, etc', I don't see how this chain can lead any other way. To me, it is simple. Please bear with me -- I am being earnest here, not spiteful. The thing I have most strongly learned through this issue is that we must come together in love, not pull apart in opposition. I treat those who agree with Ordain Women as I treat members of the LGBT community and those in my own family who are aggressively anti-Mormon: I do not agree with you, but I love love love love love you all the same. If we must have opposition (and the scriptures tell us we must, in all things), then it must be existed in only in a spirit of love.
The thing is, to believe in some parts of the doctrine -- that Joseph Smith's tale is true, maybe, or that the Book of Mormon is true -- but believe that today's leadership is not only NOT following the counsel of God, but actively going against it...I would not fight to change such a church. I would fight to banish it from every corner of the earth, and see every last leader punished. It would be, to me, to say that The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints is that great and abominable church spoken of in the scriptures. Here's another, sort of round-about way of seeing it: I believe that God is with our church, I have seen it many times in my own life and the lives of those around me. God would not be with a church that fought against him. So we must not be against him.
While prayerfully contemplating where I stood on the current social issues raised by OW, I came to a conclusion that I believe in with every beat of my heart shoveling blood through my veins:
We are not a part of this church to change the church. We are a part of this church to change ourselves.
"For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, saith the LORD."
Isaiah 55:8
I will continue to reconcile myself to a feeling on this subject, but I will also not let it consume me. As Kayla Lemmon put it in her recent blog post, "We, as a church, need to learn something from this event. We need to learn that the fight that really needs to be fought is the fight to win souls to Christ. No other agenda. No other reason to gain followers. No other reason to be involved. It’s to rise up as women and men in the gospel–together–to reach others." I will try to extricate myself from this fight and focus on my own spiritual betterment, which desperately needs my attention. The church will take care of its women, its men, its young and its old, its strong and weak and new and veteran. I trust it to do this. I will pray that this trust and peace can spread throughout all those troubled by recent social issues. Trust and peace. Onward and upward.
Katie Golden
Eric's blog post: http://www.mormoniconoclast.com/pain/
Kayla's blog post: http://lemmonythings.com/2014/06/25/kate-kelly-was-not-kicked-out-of-heaven/